Home 5 News 5 ACFID Blog 5 Why conflict of interest needs to be more than a standing agenda item

Why conflict of interest needs to be more than a standing agenda item

Jan 19, 2020 | ACFID Blog

ACFID 2022-23 Supplementary Federal Budget Analysis

Managing conflict of interest, real or perceived, is hugely important – not only for good governance, but also for building trust amongst stakeholders. If it is not managed well, it can damage the reputation of the agency and even the wider sector, eroding public trust.

The way an ACFID member demonstrates commitment to managing conflict of interest is through a policy and procedural approach. The Code at 7.4.3 is quite specific, such that the policy/procedure needs to define a conflict of interest, require the disclosure of conflicts of interest not only by responsible persons but also by volunteers and staff, articulate ways for recording and addressing conflicts of interest, and also cover open and fair procurement of goods and services.

In addition to this, the Code also requires this policy to be available on members’ websites, in the interests of transparency.

What is a conflict of interest?

There are various definitions– the ACFID Code doesn’t prescribe a specific definition, and each organisation will need to define it for themselves. The ACNC’s ‘Managing Conflicts of Interest Guide’ says: “A conflict of interest occurs when your personal interests conflict with your responsibility to act in the best interests of your charity. The term ‘personal interests’ does not need to be your own interest, but may also arise from the interests of your family friends, or other organisations you are involved with. It also includes a conflict between your duty to the charity and another duty that you have (for example, to another charity).” Beyond the definition, there are three accepted types of conflicts; actual, potential and perceived.

Approaches to Code compliance for managing Conflict of Interest

Members have varying approaches to managing conflict of interest, some addressing the issue head-on in a dedicated policy, others peppering their approaches through multiple avenues and pre-existing policies and procedural documents. Either approach is fine as long as the whole picture, when taken together, adequately satisfies the Code requirements and is adequately documented.

Relying on conflict of interest being a standing agenda item at Board meetings is not enough. This is a baseline approach that might cover ‘responsible persons’ but managing conflict of interest is not something that concerns only senior managers and Board members. All employees and volunteers of an organisation are responsible for behaving ethically, and should be conscious of this. Any employee or volunteer who thinks that they might have a conflict, or who believes that another person in the organisation may be in a situation of possible conflict of interest, has an ethical responsibility to bring the matter forward. An open workplace culture should encourage discussion and identification of these matters at any stage.

How to manage a conflict of interest

Importantly, any conflict of interest policy should be complemented by a documented procedure which sets out what to do when a conflict is identified. Conflicts of interest are part of life and will arise from time to time. When managed well they do not need to be feared, and most situations don’t require drastic measures. The Canadian Council for International Cooperation (CCIC)’s Practical Introduction to Managing Conflict of Interest Situations provides the DDDD approach along with some RRRRR responses:

  1. Declare it
  2. Discuss it
  3. Deal with it (you could RESTRICT involvement, RECRUIT third party, REMOVE the individual, RELINQUISH the private interest, or RESIGN)
  4. Document what has been done.

…but how do you know?

How do you know if you are in a conflict of interest situation, whether actual, potential or perceived? Identifying a situation where a conflict of interest exists, might exist, or could appear to exist is not always easy. Individual situations can be complex.

Take this quick test to see where you stand.

Clare Petre

Clare Petre

Clare was most recently the Energy & Water Ombudsman NSW for over 16 years. Prior to that she was a Senior Assistant Commonwealth Ombudsman. This work has given her in depth experience in complaint handling, identification of systemic issues, application of codes and standards. She was Chair of the Australian and New Zealand Ombudsman Association for several years. Clare has extensive experience in the community sector, with government, and the media. She has worked with community legal centres - Redfern Legal Centre, the Intellectual Disability Rights Service, and the Public Interest Advocacy Centre. She has also worked as a reporter with ABC TV’s 4 Corners and The Investigators, and in the health system. Clare has served on a range of NSW and Commonwealth government advisory bodies, and on the boards of community groups, including ACOSS and Performance Space. Clare is currently a Board member of Energy Consumers Australia and City West Housing. She chairs the consumer advisory panels for the Australian Securities & Investment Commission and the Credit and Investments Ombudsman. She is Deputy Chair of the Asylum Seekers Centre. Clare has a Bachelor of Social Studies, Diploma of Criminology, M.Sc Social Administration.

About

A woman in a brightly coloured scarf peers through coffee bean bushes on either side of her.

Annual Report 2021-22

Reporting on ACFID’s activities to ensure transparency and accountability

ACFID

ACFID is the peak body for Australian NGOs involved in international development and humanitarian action.

Our PARTNERSHIPS

ACFID works and engages with a range of strategic partners in addition to our members.

GOVERNANCE

ACFID is governed by its Board, ACFID Council, and various expert and governance committees.

Members

Conference

Conference 2022

HEALTHY PLANET, HEALTHY COMMUNITIES.

Acting with evidence, equity and inclusion for a resilient future.

Meet our Members

The ACFID membership is comprised of Australian NGOs that actively work in the international aid and development sector.

Become a member

Joining ACFID means joining an experienced and powerful mix of like-minded organisations committed to good international development practice.

Membership types & fees

ACFID has two types of organisational membership: Full Membership and Affiliate Membership.

State of the Sector

The State of the Sector Report provides a comprehensive and robust analysis of the state of the Australian aid and development sector.

NGO Aid Map

ACFID’s NGO Aid Map allows the Australian public and stakeholders to explore the work of ACFID Members around the world.

Development Practice Committee

The DPC is an expert advisory group of development practitioners leading good practice within the sector.

Our Focus

Budget Analysis

Federal Budget 2022 Analysis

Facts and figures on how aid is presented in this year’s annual budget

Strategic Plan

ACFID prioritises a robust response to climate change and pressure on civil society in developing countries, as well as other key priorities.

Emergency Aid

ACFID Members provide vital life-saving assistance in the immediate aftermath of an emergency.

Climate Change

Action on climate change is one of ACFID’s highest priorities, as it is an existential threat to humanity and our development.

Civil Society

Civil societies are a cornerstone of regional stability and ensure that the voices of the marginalised are heard.

Supporting NGOS

Supporting NGOs as Valuable Partners.

Inclusive & locally led development

Walking the talk on inclusive development.

Humanitarian Action

Taking humanitarian action for those in greatest need.

Elevating Development

Elevating Development to the Heart of Australia’s International Engagement.

PSEAH

Improving standards, practice and culture to prevent and respond to sexual exploitation, abuse and harassment.

Code of Conduct

A small girl stands in front of a multi-coloured finger paint artwork, with a blue paint covered hand

2022-23 ACFID Code of Conduct Review

The ACFID Code of Conduct is periodically reviewed to ensure it continues to reflect good practice and the needs of ACFID and its members.

Code of Conduct

The Code is a voluntary, self-regulatory industry code of good practice.

About the Code

Find out more about the Code of Conduct and how it operates.

Good Practice Toolkit

Overview and practical resources, and examples to support the implementation of the Code.

Spotlight on the Code

Provides a thematic ‘deep dive’ into each of the nine Quality Principles in the Code

Compliance

This section outlines the responsibility to be taken by each Member to ensure compliance with the Code.

Complaints Handling

How to make a complaint and information on the Code’s independent mechanism to address concerns relating to an ACFID Members’ conduct.

Other Standards

Mapping the Code with other professional standards and principles in the humanitarian and aid sector in Australia and internationally

Loading...